A recent effort was
a listing of the top 15 strange comments overheard
in the library by librarians. One of them cracked me up:
- "Did Charles Dickens ever write anything fun?"
Well, Charlie was
rather obsessed about poverty and classism in old Europe, particularly as they
affected poor young boys growing up. Rather like his own upbringing when his father was thrown into debtor's prison. But he actually had the richest sense of
humor. It is found in his characterizations of the characters who dominate all his
books. Real people. Not heroes. Greedy, poor, unclean, brutal people sometimes.
Snooty pretenders. Wizened old cranks.
You know. Like your
neighbors.
Like the Senate.
And I smile to think
that Dickens wrote his books in installments some 150 years ago. The installments were published
in newspapers, and he was the rage of the time. He effectively blogged his
novels.
Miss Havisham |
The Book I will
sottoize a page from is "Great Expectations", which is a story of our
hero young "Pip", fatherless, motherless and living at the start of
the book with his older sister and her husband Joe. Joe is a blacksmith, not
the brightest iron in the furnace but good of heart and protective of young
Pip. A mysterious benefactor arranges for Pip to go to London to clerk at a law
firm for a gruff cheapskate lawyer named Mr. Jaggers. The separation from Joe
is heartwrenching but it is best for Pip, a very bright boy. Joe knows he can
show Pip no future.
Jaggers is an
excellent lawyer, as we will see in a moment.
Pip falls in love
with the mysterious and unpredictable Estella, a resident at the remarkable
Miss Havisham's grand residence. Miss Havisham was jilted on her wedding day
and remains frozen in time, hung up on the crash of love lost. Love's grip is a
key theme of the novel, and Pip gets gripped by Estella.
But let's just take
a moment to step back as Pip gets to know Mr. Jaggers, courtesy of a tour of
the law firm by a law clerk at the firm named Wemmick.
Wemmick invites Pip
to his house some time, an invitation which Pip accepts. Then Wemmick asks:
<
< < < < - - - - > > > > >
"Have
you dined with Mr. Jaggers yet?"
"Not
yet."
"Well,"
said Wemmick. "he'll give you wine, and good wine. I'll give you punch,
and not bad punch. And now I'll tell you something. When you go to dine with
Mr. Jaggers, look at his housekeeper."
"Shall
I see something very uncommon?"
"Well,
said Wemmick, "you'll see a wild beast tamed. Not so very uncommon, you'll
tell me. I reply, that depends on the original wildness of the beast, and the
amount of taming. It won't lower your opinion of Mr. Jaggers's powers. Keep
your eye on it."
I
told him I would do so, with all the interest and curiosity that his
preparation awakened. As I was taking my departure, he asked me if I would like
to devote five minutes to seeing Mr. Jaggers "at it"?
JoeAm lookalike. Charles Dickens. |
For
several reasons, and not the least because I didn't clearly know what Mr.
Jaggers would be found to be "at", I replied in the affirmative. We
dived into the City, and came up in a crowded police court, where a blood
relation (in the murderous sense) of the deceased with the fanciful taste in
brooches was standing at the bar, uncomfortably chewing something; while my
guardian had a woman under examination or cross-examination - I don't know
which - and was striking her, and the bench, and everybody with awe. If
anybody, of whatsoever degrees, said a word that he didn't approve of, he
instantly required to have it "taken down." If anybody wouldn't make
an admission, he said, "I'll have it out of you!" and if anybody made
an admission, he said "Now I have got you!" The magistrates shivered
under a single bite of his finger. Thieves and thieftakers hung in dread
rapture on his words, and shrank when a hair of his eyebrows turned in their
direction. Which side he was on, I couldn't make out, for he seemed to me to be
grinding the whole place in a mill; I only know that when I stole out on
tiptoe, he was not on the side of the bench, for he was making the legs of the
old gentleman who presided quite convulsive under the table by his
denunciations of his conduct as the representative of British law and justice
in that chair that day.
<
< < < < - - - - > > > > >
So, did Charles
Dickens ever write anything fun?
I don't know about
you, but Dickens had me smiling all the way through this book. His people come
alive, from the mention of their names to their quirks of their lives. The
travails the characters face are made more intense by the vividness of the
pictures in which they perform.
"He'll
give you wine, and good wine. I'll give you punch, and not bad punch."
The line shows
Wemmick to be a good man, a comparatively poor, underclass man, who knows his
place in life, yet keeps it in healthy - indeed, tasteful - perspective.
What a cast of
characters. Tell me the names aren't fun:
- Miss Havisham
- Abel Magwitch
- Joe Gargery
- Mr. Pumblechook
- Mr. Jaggers
- Mr. Wemmick
- Herbert Pocket
And the active
writing style.
We
dived into the City, and came up in a crowded police court, where a blood
relation (in the murderous sense) of the deceased with the fanciful taste in
brooches was standing at the bar, uncomfortably chewing something . . .
We didn't just walk
downtown and into the City court to watch the victim's relative testify.
The magistrates shivered under a single bite of his finger.
Brilliant, Dude. Gives me shivers, too. Dickens is my idol. Words are scalpels for him, or feathers to caress, or microscopes under which people look a lot like bugs.
The magistrates shivered under a single bite of his finger.
Brilliant, Dude. Gives me shivers, too. Dickens is my idol. Words are scalpels for him, or feathers to caress, or microscopes under which people look a lot like bugs.
- The book is a mystery, too. Who is Pip's benefactor?
- And a romance. Will the heart-smitten Pip marry the pretty and teasing Estella?
- And a bit scary. The creepy pale face in the window at Miss Havisham's dark, foreboding mansion. Or Pip's meetings with the unbalanced Miss Havisham, an old woman trapped for years in sorrow and anger.
But more than
anything, the book is good for the mind and soul.
An easy read? No
way. British language of 150 years ago was wretchedly twisted; strained
through the imagination of the verbose Charles Dickens, it assumes entirely new
shapes of grand contortion.
Is the climbing of a
mountain easy? Afterwards, yes.
Is Dickens fun?
The best.
Ah, a literary digression. A little trip down memory lane, a timely relief to skip our preoccupation with snooty politicians and greedy candidates.
ReplyDeleteBut, no, there’s the comparison to real people “like the Senate”. Oh, well, I might give old Charlie a try (ex Project Gutenberg) and see whether he can make me laugh where I would cry, the beloved country.
There is laughter and there is mirth. Mirth is to be found in the fallibility of sincerely dismal characters. The humor in the book is more of the mirthy kind. It helps put the real world in perspective, that there always were and always will be "creatures" amongst us, and our good middle path should have us treading amongst them heads up and smiles ready at the draw. The alternative, as you recognize, is tears.
DeleteI haven't read any Dickens. The long run-ons may put me to sleep but your appreciation of Dickens certainly perked my interest. My favorite politician before the Corona impeachment, Teddy Boy Locsin, liked Little Dorrit the most or so he says in a broadcast. I doubt very much, though, the term "positively Dickensian" refers to anything humorous.
ReplyDeleteDocB
Ha, yes, he does know how to pen a sleep inducing sentence. I just take it very slow to begin with then it picks up when I get used to the entanglements. Dickensian. By dickens, that is a good word. Meaning dark and entangled, probably. I'm too lazy to look it up.
ReplyDeleteDid Charles Dickens ever write anything fun?
ReplyDeleteBah humbug!
A Christmas Carol has got to be one of the few stories written from that literary period that had me laughing from the very beginning. "Old Marley was dead as a doornail". Dickens' wry sense of humor getting a warm-up. I can think of only one other classic that I found just as funny, Jane Austen's Pride and Prejudice. Are there any more?
I need to revisit Great Expectations, it's the only other Dickens book I've really read. I'm not so sure it made me smile. I think it made me angry, at Estella and Ms Havisham mostly, maybe the anger kept me from enjoying the more lighthearted moments to the story. Or maybe I was just too wrapped up in my own teenage angst, too sullen to find any humor in the story of an orphan boy named Pip. Now that I think about it, that name alone should probably have made me smile.
Ahahahahaha. "Old Marley was as dead as a doornail". That is Charles Dickens in a sentence. No "passing away" for him, no sir.
DeleteI rather think Dickens is enjoyed best with a lot of drudge in one's past, and the idealism of a teenage girl is unlikely to provide enough of it. You should re-read this book and see if a smile doesn't keep sneaking onto your face at those marvelous descriptions. When you recognize some old curmudgeon lawyer or teacher from your past, or a good-hearted lummox like Joe Gargery.
Dickens paints with words. He paints character. And characters.
Dickens' love and lust for women was copied by Sotto. Dickens is forever fun while Sotto has been trying hard all his life to be funny to his fans. And Charles never plagiarized in his lifetime!
DeleteOlympia WA fan
Olympia, Yes, can you imagine Dickens lifting paragraphs from Cervantes or some other popular writer? That is so funny. I rather think Dickens is just one of those guys who opens his brain and words flow out like water, prettily aligned and powerfully multi-dimensional. Like the dude was an artistic genius.
DeleteWell, he might just as well have had Sotto in mind with these lines: (also from A Christmas Carol )
Delete"This boy is Ignorance. This girl is Want. Beware them both and all of their degree! But most of all beware this boy, for on his brow I see that which is written is Doom.... "
Now as for the girl... another senator comes to mind.
My God, if you will pardon the expression, but that is good. I do believe I must dig up "A Christmas Carol" for its grand wisdoms. I always thought it was about sugar plums; oh, wait, that was a different story.
DeleteI simply can't imagine what senatorial girl you have in mind . . .
I can!
DeleteSotto is rich, never started poor, unlike Charles, who mined his humble beginnings to create those characters. Sotto seems satisfied mining the Pope blog and the RFK speech. Poor soul.
ReplyDeleteDocB
To be fair to Sotto, I have to say he's a certified song writer but being a tunesmith is different from being a senator of the republic.
ReplyDeleteDocB
Then there are the boxers and dictator's wives . . .
DeleteJoe,
ReplyDeleteId like to seek your permission to publish here a short essay I am writing on "An Alternative View of Pedro Calungsod (in the context of the Spanish-Chamorro Wars 1672-1698). Ill finish it within a few days.
In summary, it's about the parallel experience of the Chamorros (now Guamanians) at the hands of the Spanish imperialists- very similar to the Philippine experience- the use of force, the imposition of a foreign culture, the disrespect for indigenous cultures, etc.
Viewed from this context, Pedro Calungsod was a loyal ally and assistant of the invading Spaniards, an enabler of imperialism.
Could be very controversial.
Certainly, andrew. Send it to the e-mail address in the "Contact Us" tab when you have it ready. And if you have a photo you'd like, attach that, too. Otherwise I'll find one.
DeleteAs for controversy, I'm reminded of a mentor of mine at the bank (British; they owned us at the time) who was always challenging and provoking the executives. He confided in me it was one of his main principles, "you know, Joe, chemical reactions work faster if a little heat is applied". I rather think the same about thinking.
There's a photo of Vice President Binay with a Calungsod "Ken" doll.
DeleteRight column under teaser.
DeleteThat photo's a rich source for pundits, Joe.
DeleteThe Philippines'first black vice president named Jesus Joseph and Mary (JEJOMAR)holding a Ken Calungsod doll!
Will submit my article today, Joe. Will leave the choice of photo to you and your wicked sense of humor. :)
Great, andrew. I look forward to it.
DeleteThanks for the explanation of JEJOMAR. I didn't know that, and now understand why humility is not his trademark.